An unreliable narrator explains three brutal murders in 19th century Scotland

His Bloody Project features an unreliable narrator.

1869. Rural Scotland. A 17-year-old boy named Roderick Macrae has brutally murdered a neighboring man and two of his children. He freely confesses to the crime, stating that “I carried out these acts with the sole purpose of delivering my father from the tribulations he has lately suffered” at the hands of the murdered man. But is that really why Roddy carried out this hideous crime? In His Bloody Project, Scottish author Graeme Macrae Burnet probes the young man’s motives through a compilation of documents. Included are Roddy’s detailed and lengthy confession, transcripts of interviews with some of his neighbors and from the trial, and excerpts from a book written by one of the doctors who interviewed the young man in prison. In Burnet’s skillful telling, the truth only slowly emerges.


His Bloody Project: Documents Relating to the Case of Roderick Macrae by Graeme Macrae Burnet (2016) 300 pages

@@@@@ (5 out of 5)

Man Booker Prize Finalist


An unreliable narrator explains three brutal murders

His Bloody Project masquerades as a true crime account, but it is of course a novel. Burnet uses the platform of this grim story to reveal the feudal conditions under which landless farmers lived in 19th-century Scotland. And that tale is none the less grim. An absentee lord holds an estate that encompasses several villages and a huge expanse of nearby land. In the Big House, the lord’s “factor” rules but is himself a distant presence to the villagers. Within each village, a constable represents the factor and thus the lord. He is the face of the law, and if he is inclined to rule harshly, there is no one to stop him. And therein lies the tale.

Roddy, his ailing father, and his older sister have eked out a meager existence in the village of Culduie. But when Lachlan Broad is elected constable, their lives gradually grow more difficult and more painful. And this is the backdrop, and the ostensible reason, for Roddy’s murder of Broad and his children. Burnet is a skillful writer who uses the overworked device of the unreliable narrator in a clever and ultimately successful way.

For additional reading

This is one of the many Mysteries and thrillers set in Scotlandthat I’ve reviewed here.

You might also enjoy my posts:

If you’re looking for exciting historical novels, check out Top 10 historical mysteries and thrillers reviewed here (plus 100 others).

And you can always find my most popular reviews, and the most recent ones, plus a guide to this whole site, on the Home Page.

Spread The Word!